The 8 Best Pie Dishes in 2019

If you desire to make perfect golden pies, then you should equip yourself with just the right tools. A pie dish promises beautiful results to the user in the form of evenly browned crispy crust. Pie dishes are available in wide range of materials and styles. We have spent hours in studying the top pie dishes available in the market today.     

Our review lists all kinds of pie dishes that let you make perfectly cooked and delicious pies for your loved ones. You can go through this detailed review which has been provided after taking into account all the essential factors to consider before buying the best pie dish.

Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Pie Dishes


[table id=76 /]

1. Fiesta Deep Dish Pie Baker

Highlighted Features

  • Features perfect standard pie size
  • Pie dish is made of vitrified ceramic body
  • Lead-free glaze
  • Made in the USA
  • Backed by 5-year chip resistance warranty by the makers

Fiesta Pie Baker is fabulously designed and perfect for making quiches and pies. It features standard pie size. The durable glaze renders it perfect for everyday use. This deep dish pie baker can hold filling for any average pie recipe. The rim and the inner lip of the plate are deep enough to ensure easy removal from the oven.

Fiesta pie ware offered by Homer Laughlin company are oven proof, lead-free, freezer proof, and microwave safe. The products offered by the company including this pie baker have stood the test of time. You can count on the offerings of this company. Fiesta is one of the most collected dinnerware in the US.

Pros

  • Plus Circle
    No overflows or drips
  • Plus Circle
    Cooks pies to perfection
  • Plus Circle
    Is oven, microwave and dishwasher safe
  • Plus Circle
    Features sturdy construction

Cons

  • The dish is quite shallow

2. Pyrex Easy Grab 9.5" Glass Pie Dish

Highlighted Features

  • The pie dish measures 9 ½ inches
  • Is microwave and dishwasher safe

This inexpensive glass pie dish is ideal for those who are fans of glass dishes. This see-through glass plate lets you check on the browning of the bottom crust with much ease. The scalloped rim is wide enough to offer a secure grip to the users. 

The fluted rim lets the users make crimped-edge piecrust with ease. The best thing is that this Pyrex pie dish is easy to clean. All you need to do is put it in a dishwasher. Designed from nonporous glass, this pie plate does not absorb odors, stain or warp.

Pros

  • Made in the USA
  • Plus Circle
    Backed by 2-year warranty from the makers
  • Plus Circle
    Contoured edge results in a beautiful golden crust
  • Plus Circle
    Is freezer and fridge safe

Cons

  • Glass plate tends to shatter if the instructions are not followed carefully

3. Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate

Highlighted Features

  • Basic 9” pie dish
  • Made in the USA
  • Ideal for making cobblers, breads, cakes, casseroles, lasagnas and pies
  • Glass is safe to use in dishwashers, freezers, fridges, microwaves and preheated oven
  • Convenient glass structure lets you cook straight from the oven to the table

Pyrex Bakeware Pie Plate is an inexpensive option for those looking for looking to make delicious quiches, pies and more. You can try freezer pie, bake and no-bake recipes with this pie plate with much ease. The Pyrex glass is nonporous and would not absorb food stains, food flavors or any odors.

The convenient glass structure permits the users to cook and serve directly from the oven to the table. Cleaning is easy to accomplish in a dishwasher. Made in the USA, this product is backed by 2-year limited warranty by the company. This hints of the trust that the company has in its products.

Pros

  • Glass used in designing has a nonporous surface
  • Plus Circle
    Pyrex glass would not absorb food flavors, stains and odors

Cons

  • Is quite shallow

4. Good Cook Red Ceramic Pie Plate

Highlighted Features

  • This pie pan is pretty sturdy
  • Dish is sturdy and well-made
  • Doubles as a beautiful serve ware

This 9 inch pie pan is thick and sturdy. This ceramic pie plate features a glazed exterior. The cream colored interior is just perfect for both oven and table use. This pie dish is sturdier and is quite big. This product is dishwasher, oven, freezer and microwave safe.

This Good Cook baking pan has been designed with thorough understanding of everyday kitchen needs. The quality of this bakeware is exceptional. The oven to table design of this pie plate is an added advantage to its users. This baking dish is perfect for making deep dishes such as shepherd’s pie.

Pros

  • Plus Circle
    Features a glazed exterior
  • Plus Circle
    Is dishwasher, oven, freezer and microwave safe
  • Plus Circle
    Superior built and quality

Cons

  • Is quite fragile

5. Emile Henry HR Modern Classic Pie Dish

Highlighted Features

  • Made from high-fired burgundy clay and other natural materials
  • Promises superior heat retention
  • Oven safe to up to 520ºF
  • Microwave, broiler and oven safe

Emile Henry is renowned for offering high quality ceramic cooking utensils since 1850s. All its products are made from natural materials and are backed by 10-year guarantee by the makers. The Modern Classic collection has been designed in France and features shapes, dimensions and capacities suitable for American recipes.

This Modern Classic collection has been designed to attract American consumers while retaining the performance and design elements of Emile Henry. This ceramic dish lets you cook evenly baked pie which melts into your mouth. This pie dish can be used to serve directly on table straight from the oven.

All Emile Henry products have been designed in France and are backed by ten years guarantee by the makers. The best thing is that the product is easy to clean with soap and water. You can also place it in a dishwasher.

Pros

  • Can be used directly from freezer or refrigerator to a table or hot oven
  • Plus Circle
    Is scratch resistant and durable  
  • Plus Circle
    Glaze is extremely hard

Cons

  • You cannot see the bottom of the crust unlike pie dishes
  • Sizes are slightly different from 9 inch pie dish

6. Baker’s Advantage Ceramic Deep Pie Dish

Highlighted Features

  • Made from professional quality stoneware of low porosity
  • Features a glazed exterior
  • Ceramic construction promises even heating for a perfect crust

This elegantly designed deep pie dish boasts of a fluted edge which results in an exceptional pie with a fluted crust. Made from low porosity ceramics, this deep pie dish promises increased durability to the users. This pie dish can hold wide variety of recipes when compared to shallower plates. The ruffled lip helps in forming beautiful flutings on the pie.

The Baker’s Advantage Deep Dish pie plate is quite affordable and features a reliable construction. This dish weighs 2 lbs. and 11 ounces and feels heftier when held. This pie dish model delivers exceptional baking performance as the premium models at a slightly lesser price. This pie dish is dishwasher, broiler and microwave safe.

Pros

  • Ceramic deep pie dish measures 9 ½ inches in diameter
  • Plus Circle
    Fluted edge results in fluted crust
  • Plus Circle
    Is affordable and features reliable construction 

Cons

  • The edges are straight instead of sloped which makes it hard to cut and lift a pie wedge neatly

7. International Cookware Borosilicate Glass Pie Dish

Highlighted Features

  • Tempering promises a double resistance to thermal shock
  • Is stain and scratch resistant
  • Made from safe borosilicate glass

This pie dish has been designed with borosilicate glass in France. Offered by a reliable cookware brand, this glass pie dish serves multiple purposes. Borosilicate is the only glass that can be used directly from freezer to oven. It is also safe to use in an oven, dishwasher, freezer, fridge and microwave.

The surface is absolutely smooth and nonporous. It is free from harmful chemicals such as bisphenol. This pie dish can resist high thermal shock. The users can prepare, cook, store and serve in this pie dish. It is stain and scratch resistant for long lasting use and durability.

You can make scrumptious cheesy quiche and apple pie in this pie ware to impress your guests and loved ones. The handles promise easy transportation from one place to another. This product is backed by ten-year manufacturer’s warranty. This pie dish is also dishwasher safe.

Pros

  • Backed by 5-year manufacturer’s guarantee
  • Plus Circle
    Can be used directly from freezer to dinner table
  • Plus Circle
    Is refrigerator safe

Cons

  • The size is too small for traditional sized pies 

8. Emile Henry Ruffled Pie Dish

Highlighted Features

  • Made from natural materials
  • High-fired clay has been used in designing
  • Promises superior heat retention
  • Burgundy clay has heat retention and even-heat diffusion properties
  • Keep food hot on the table for long
  • Resistant to temperature fluctuations

This ruffled pie dish is ideal for making delicious fruity desserts with pears, apples and cherries. You can also use this for making cakes. All Emily Henry products can be used in ovens, dishwashers, freezers and microwave ovens. The color of this pie dish remains intact despite regular use.

You can also make savories, salads and gratins in this Emile Henry Ruffled Pie Dish. The bright color of this dish adds a touch of color at your dinner table. All Emile Henry products are made in France and backed by 10-year guarantee.

Pros

  • Is microwave, oven and broiler safe
  • Plus Circle
    Can be used directly from a freezer to hot oven
  • Plus Circle
    Backed by 10-year warranty against manufacturing defects

Cons

  • Tends to chip if not maintained appropriately

Things to Consider Before Buying a Pie Dish  

Material 

Pie dishes are designed with numerous materials. Each material has its own purpose to serve. If you take glass pie plates for instance, these ensure that your pies have perfect golden crusts. Pie dishes made from glass retain oven heat and can be used in a freezer, oven, microwave and a dishwasher without any apprehensions.

Ceramic pie dishes offer similar features too. However, these are larger in size in comparison to standard pie dishes. Disposable foil pie pans are also available in the market. These are beneficial to people who frequently go on camping or are not fond of investing their time and energy on doing the dishes. Foil pie pans are smaller in dimensions when compared to standard pie dishes.

Cast iron pans are also popular. These are heavy and promise golden brown crusts to the users. However, these are not microwave safe and hence may not appeal to everybody.   

Size

Pie pans come in different designs and sizes. Both shallow and deep dish styles of pie pans can be found in the market. Those who are cooking just for themselves can go for small sized pie pans. Those cooking for their entire family can look for other options. The standard pie pan size is 9” and the sides usually measure 1 ¼”.  

Deep Dish 

Although deep dish pans are not standard, these are preferred by many. You can easily find ceramic, foil and glass deep dish pans owing to their popularity.     

Rim 

The rim of the pan is what that offers a special design to the crust. Some edges are smooth and some are fluted. You can choose a model as per your liking. You can also weigh in other factors to make a final decision.  

5/5 - (4 votes)

Leave a Comment