Best Pie Plate

The 8 Best Pie Plates in 2019

Novice cooks may have a hard time mastering making golden and flaky pies. The right tools and patience can help them achieve beautiful results. A pie plate is the secret to obtaining a great pie. These plates are available in numerous styles and made from different materials. This review will help you find the right pie plate to make perfect pie every time.

We have spent hours finding the perfect pie plates that can make a significant difference in your lives. There are several things that you can look into while looking for right pie pans for your baking needs. You can look into the factors to consider before buying the best pie plate. This will help you find something that fits into your requirements and makes a significant difference in your kitchen.

Best Pick

Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate- 9.5”

Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate stands out among other brands and is a renowned name when it comes to kitchen bakeware. This fluted rim pie plate can be used for making pies, quiches and a lot more. You can make crimped-edge crust owing to the fluted rim of this plate. This easy grab pie plate measures 9.5” in diameter. The glass would not absorb any stain or odors. This pie plate is oven, dishwasher, freezer and microwave safe. Easy Grab plate can be used in the oven and also on the table for serving. It is easy to clean and is backed by a 2-year warranty from the makers.

Budget Pick

Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate by NA

Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate can be used for making quiches, pies and a lot more. You can use this pie plate for making no-bake recipes, for making a freezer pies and for any recipes that requires baking. This pie plate can be cleaned easily in a dishwasher. Made in the USA, this product is backed by a limited 2 year warranty by the makers.   This pie plate is a great budget option. It has a nonporous surface which would not absorb any food stains, flavors or odors. The convenient glass structure permits you to cook and serve straight from the oven in this pie plate. The glass used in designing is safe to use in freezers, microwaves and preheated ovens.

If you are looking to add a pie plate promising great value to your kitchen collection, then you can consider the products listed in this review. If you still find it difficult to shortlist a great option for your kitchen, then you can consider the recommendations provided by us.


1. Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate- 9.5”

Highlighted Features

  • Made from nonporous glass
  • Does not absorb odors, stain or warp
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
  • Made in the USA
  • Backed by 2-year warranty 

Pyrex brand stands out among other brands and is a renowned name when it comes to kitchen bakeware. This fluted rim pie plate can be used for making pies, quiches and a lot more. You can make crimped-edge crust owing to the fluted rim of this plate. This pie plate would make a great addition to your bakeware collection.

This easy grab pie plate measures 9.5” in diameter. The glass would not absorb any stain or odors. This pie plate is oven, dishwasher, freezer and microwave safe. Several bakers prefer using glass plates as it helps them track what is happening during the cooking process.

Pyrex glass pie plates impart a lot of versatility to your baking and can be used for quiches, casseroles and pieces along with other foods. This Easy Grab plate can be used in the oven and also on the table for serving. It just looks great while doing its job. It is easy to clean and is backed by a 2-year warranty from the makers.

Pros

  • Is freezer, fridge, microwave and oven safe
  • Plus Circle
    Contoured edges helps in creating beautiful crust
  • Plus Circle
    Great alternative to plain pie plates
  • Plus Circle
    No cold or overcooked spots

Cons

  • Tends to slide too easily

2. Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate by NA

Highlighted Features

  • Average sized pie plate ideal for most of the recipes
  • Is transparent and lets you see the bottom of the crust while baking
  • Easy to clean and store
  • Sturdy plate
  • Has a non-porous surface

Pyrex pie plates can be used for making quiches, pies and a lot more. You can use this pie plate for making no-bake recipes, for making a freezer pies and for any recipes that requires baking. This pie plate can be cleaned easily in a dishwasher. Made in the USA, this product is backed by a limited 2 year warranty by the makers.

This pie plate is a great budget option. It has a nonporous surface which would not absorb any food stains, flavors or odors. The convenient glass structure permits you to cook and serve straight from the oven in this pie plate. The glass used in designing is safe to use in freezers, microwaves and preheated ovens.

Pros

  • Does not absorb any stains, flavors and odors
  • Plus Circle
    Is safe to use in preheated ovens
  • Plus Circle
    Is ideal for making cobblers, breads, cakes, casseroles, lasagnas, pies and a lot more
  • Plus Circle
    Simple 9” pie plate
  • Plus Circle
    Made in the USA

Cons

  • Is smaller than average pie plates and has no handles

3. Anchor Hocking 79033 Pie Plate

Highlighted Features

  • Measures 6-inch in diameter
  • Made in USA
  • Clear glass, thick build  
  • Is sturdy
  • Ideal for desserts and small pies

This 6-inch diameter pie plate is ideal for those who are planning to make desserts and small pies. It comes with a handle which makes it quite convenient for the users to manage it. The handle offers much support while moving the pie plate from the oven to the serving table.

The non-reactive glass construction does not absorb any flavors from the recipes as it is odor resistant. This pie plate is dishwasher safe. It is also microwave and oven safe. The sturdy, thick clear glass construction makes this design last for a long time.

Pros

  • Is easy to clean and use
  • Plus Circle
    Is dishwasher, microwave and oven safe
  • Plus Circle
    Measures 7.25” in width including the handle
  • Plus Circle
    Odor resistant and non-reactive glass

Cons

  • It has a narrow rim and not a flat one unlike other pie plates

4. Nordic Ware Hi-Dome Covered Aluminum Pie Pan

Highlighted Features

  • Made from pure aluminum
  • Will never rust for a lifetime
  • Is durable
  • Baked goods bake uniformly
  • Superior heat conductivity

If you intend to invest in a huge pie plate, then this 2 quart capacity pie pan would make a great investment. The rim of this pie plate offers secure grip to the users. It is easy to carry around. Made from uncoated aluminum, this pie plate is durable and would last for a long time.

The high dome offers enough space so that the top portion of the pie does not get squashed by the cover. The material promises even heating and features a wire of galvanized steel arounds the rim to impart additional strength. The high dome cover promises more room for the toppings.

Pros

  • Reinforced steel encapsulated steel rim
  • Plus Circle
    Does not warp
  • Plus Circle
    Easy to clean
  • Plus Circle
    Handy wash only
  • Plus Circle
    Made in the USA

Cons

  • Pan scratches easily
  • Lid is difficult to remove

5. USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pie Pan

Highlighted Features

  • Unique corrugated surface design
  • Promises quick release and evenly baked goods
  • Heavy gauge and commercial grade design
  • Made from 65% recycled steel
  • Coated with Americoat silicone nonstick coating

Commercial bakeries and professional bakers prefer bakeware made from aluminized steel owing to its high-performance capabilities and for its durability. USA Pan Bakeware features a unique fluted design. The corrugated surfaces have been engineered for enhancing nonstick properties. This also imparts additional strength to the pan and makes it warp resistant.

This aluminum steel pie pan features a high-performance design which ensures increased air flow and ideal heating distribution. This bakeware has been backed by a limited lifetime warranty by the makers. This 9-inch pan promises an easy way to the users to bake golden brown pies.

The patented AMERICOAT nonstick coating ensures easy cleanup and release of the baked items. The coating is BPA, PFOA and PTFE free. This pan has been made in the USA. It has the same high performance features that are usually enjoyed by commercial bakers. The heavy gauge steel construction ensures even heat distribution.

This reliable, durable and long lasting pie plate helps home bakers to produce professional grade baked goods.

Pros

  • Coating is BPA, PFOA and PTFE free
  • Plus Circle
    Backed by limited lifetime warranty
  • Plus Circle
    Corrugated surfaces have been engineered for enhancing nonstick properties
  • Plus Circle
    Is warp resistant  
  • Plus Circle
    High performance design and ideal heating distribution

Cons

  • The diameter of the pan is quite small

6. Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate by HIC Harold Import Co.

Highlighted Features

  • Features deep fluted edges
  • Promises secure handling in and out of the oven
  • Beautifully scalloped pie crusts
  • High-fired ceramic pie plate
  • Scratch-free glaze
  • Durable and resists cracking, odors and staining
  • Can be used from oven to the table for serving

The Rose Levy Beranbaum pie plate has been designed with deep-fluted edges for making beautifully scalloped pie crusts. This pie plate would make a perfect addition to your collection whether you are just learning how to bake pies or have already mastered it. You can make anything from shepherd’s pie, a lofty lemon meringue or a homemade apple pie in this pie plate.

This award winning pie dish has a 4-cup capacity. It can be used for making elaborative pies with decorative crusts. The edges offer secure grip and allows more secure handling into and out of the oven. It transitions beautifully from the oven to the table. It also doubles as a serving plate, baking dish and a lot more.

This pie plate has been made from high-fired ceramic. Its glaze is scratch-free. It is durable and also resists cracking, odors and staining. It is dishwasher safe and easy to cleanup. This pie plate has been designed by a renowned, award winning American baker Rose Levy Beranbaum.

Pros

  • Doubles as a baking dish as well
  • Plus Circle
    Has 4-cup capacity
  • Plus Circle
    Is dishwasher safe
  • Plus Circle
    Designed by an award winning American baker Rose Levy Beranbaum

Cons

  • Is thin walled

7. Emile Henry 366121 Modern Classic Pie Dish

Highlighted Features

  • Made in France from natural materials such as high-fired burgundy clay
  • Superior heat retention and diffusion properties
  • Keeps food hot for long
  • Resistant to temperature changes
  • Is oven, microwave and broiler safe 
  • Scratch resistant and durable

This iconic pie dish would transform your entire pie baking experience. It distributes heat evenly while baking. This pie dish is shock resistant, elegant and durable. It has been made in France from all natural materials. Made from high resistance ceramic, this pie dish diffuses heat evenly and gently.

Emile Henry pie dish is resistant to heat to up to 515 degrees F. This dish is microwave, broiler and oven safe. You can use it directly from a hot oven or freezer to the refrigerator.

Pros

  • Extremely hard glaze resists scratches
  • Plus Circle
    Durable for everyday use
  • Plus Circle
    Is easy to clean
  • Plus Circle
    Is dishwasher safe
  • Plus Circle
    10 year warranty against manufacturing defects when used in home kitchens

Cons

  • Unglazed edges can scratch counter tops and top of oven

8. Le Creuset Stoneware Pie Pan

Highlighted Features

  • Hard wearing, impermeable finish
  • Unmatched thermal resistance
  • Is broiler, oven, microwave and freezer safe
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe

This stoneware from Le Creuset features classic scalloped edging. This pie dish is ideal for making flaky crusted pies, quiches and tarts. Stoneware construction promises superior performance to the users in comparison to pie pans made from aluminum.

Le Creuset pie pan also offers steady and even heating to deliver perfect crust every time. The material is hard wearing. The thermal resistance of the material used is unmatched. The pie pan is dishwasher, broiler, oven, microwave and freezer safe. Less than 1% porosity blocks moisture absorption. This prevents rippling, crazing and cracking along the interior.

Pros

  • Less than 1% porosity
  • Plus Circle
    Blocking moisture absorption prevents rippling, crazing and cracking along the interior
  • Plus Circle
    Promises steady and even heating
  • Plus Circle
    Promises superior performance in comparison to aluminum pie pans

Cons

  • Poor packaging

Things to Consider Before Purchasing a Pie Plate

Different types of pie plates are available in the market. It is essential to go through all the features offered by different models to shortlist one for your kitchen needs. Here are the factors that you can take into consideration while looking for pie plate models.

Material 

Pie plates that are made from glass retain heat for a long time. The contents are heated evenly and the pie comes out with perfect brown crust. It also absorbs heat well. These pie plates can be used in a dishwasher, microwave, oven and also in a freezer. Ceramic pie plates are not quite common. These retain heat excellently and brown the crust perfectly. Ceramic pie plates are larger than standard sized plates. 

Disposable foils are also popular. These can be discarded after each use. These foils are smaller than standard sized pie plates. Cast iron pie plates are heavy and have a natural stick free finish. These pie plates ensure even baking and golden brown crusts. However, these cannot be put into a microwave. 

Metallic pie pans feature a nonstick coating on them. These release the pies easily and are usually made from lightweight aluminum. These are available in different sizes and are easy to clean. Stainless steel pie pans are quite durable. These are long lasting and easy to clean. You can consider all the above mentioned factors to decide the model that would be a perfect fit into your kitchen.   

Size

Pie pans are available in different sizes. You can go for individual sized pans if you are just baking a dish for yourself. You can go for full size deep dish designs if you are baking for your family and friends. The size of a standard pie pan is 9”. Deep dish pans are available in ceramic, glass and foil material. Many people prefer making deep dish pies. You can go for it if you fancy making such pies.

Rim 

The rim of a pie pan offers a specialized design to the crust. Some pie plates offer smooth edges and some offer fluted edges. If you love decorating your pies, then make sure to take a look at the models that come with beautiful rims. 

Maintenance 

It is vital to consider the amount of effort that you will have to put in maintaining the pie plates that you have invested in. Glass and cast iron pie plates usually last for decades. Glass, ceramic and metal pie pans are easy to clean and are dishwasher safe.

Cast iron pie pans demand a lot of time for maintenance. These need to be immersed in water and have to be seasoned on a regular basis. This prevents food from sticking to the surface. Glass pie plates have to be handled carefully to prevent them from shattering.  

It is vital to look into the maintenance and care tips for each material. This will help in prolonging the life of the product that you have invested in.  

Conclusion

Choosing the right pie plate requires doing some basic research to study all the options available in the market. With numerous styles and materials available to choose from, you may have a hard time picking the right model. This review can help simplify your choices. Being equipped with the necessary information will help you sort through the different styles available in the market. 

With different kinds of materials used in designing pie plates, you must weigh in the pros and cons of each material and go for the design that meets your expectations. We have mentioned the factors to consider before buying the best pie plate. You can utilize this information to sort through the numerous options available in the market.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top